Insights on Defamation Law in Egypt

Defamation is a significant legal issue in Egypt, affecting individuals, businesses, and public figures. The increasing influence of digital communication and media platforms has made defamation laws even more relevant, as false statements can spread quickly and cause severe reputational and financial damage. Unlike many Western legal systems, Egypt considers defamation to be both a civil and criminal offense, meaning that a person accused of making defamatory statements may face both financial penalties and imprisonment.

This article provides a detailed legal analysis of defamation laws in Egypt, focusing on legal definitions, relevant legislation, civil and criminal consequences, and a comparative perspective with UK defamation laws.

The Legal Concepts of Defamation under Egyptian Law

Legal Definition of Defamation in Egypt:

Under Egyptian law, defamation occurs when a person intentionally makes a false statement that harms another person’s reputation. This can take the form of:

• Slander – Spoken defamatory statements, including verbal insults and gestures.
• Libel – Written or published defamatory statements, including social media posts, news articles, blogs, and public announcements.

Egyptian defamation law does not differentiate between personal defamation (against private individuals) and public defamation (against politicians, public figures, or businesses). However, public defamation cases often carry harsher legal consequences, especially when directed at government officials, judges, or law enforcement authorities.

Unlike some legal systems where defamation cases require proof of tangible harm, Egyptian courts do not always require proof of financial loss. The mere fact that a statement damages a person’s dignity or social standing can be enough for a defamation charge.

Legal Framework Governing Defamation in Egypt

Egyptian defamation laws are governed by multiple legal statutes, which collectively define defamation, establish penalties, and regulate its application in both criminal and civil contexts.

1. Egyptian Penal Code (Law No. 58 of 1937):

The Penal Code treats defamation as a criminal offense, meaning a person accused of making defamatory statements can face both imprisonment and fines. The key articles governing defamation include:

• Article 302 – Defines defamation as the act of falsely attributing something to a person in a way that damages their honor or reputation.
• Article 303 – Establishes criminal penalties for defamation, including fines and possible imprisonment.
• Article 306 – Criminalizes public insults and slander, even if the defamatory statement was not published in writing.
• Article 308 – Imposes harsher penalties when the defamatory statement accuses a person of criminal activity, increasing the possible prison sentence.

2. Egyptian Civil Code:

In addition to criminal penalties, defamation victims can file civil lawsuits seeking monetary damages for reputational harm. Egyptian tort law allows plaintiffs to claim compensation for emotional distress, damage to professional reputation, and financial losses resulting from defamatory statements.

3. Press and Media Regulation Law (Law No. 180 of 2018):

This law regulates defamation in print and digital journalism, holding media outlets accountable for publishing false statements that damage reputations. It also outlines the legal responsibilities of journalists and the limitations on what they can publish about individuals, businesses, and public officials.

4. Cybercrime Law (Law No. 175 of 2018):

The Cybercrime Law extends defamation laws to online platforms, allowing legal action against individuals who spread defamatory content on:

• Social media (Facebook, Twitter, Instagram, TikTok, etc.)
• Online blogs and forums
• News websites and digital publications

This law criminalizes the act of publishing false and damaging information online, making Egypt one of the strictest legal systems in the region when it comes to digital defamation.

Criminal Liability for Defamation in Egypt

Since defamation is a criminal offense in Egypt, a person accused of making defamatory statements can face prosecution, fines ranging from EGP 5,000 to 30,000 (approximately USD 160 – 960), and imprisonment for up to two years. If the defamatory statement falsely accuses the victim of criminal activity, the punishment can increase to three years of imprisonment. The severity of the penalty depends on the nature of the defamatory statement, the status of the victim, and the intent of the defendant.

1. Elements of Criminal Defamation:

To successfully prosecute a defamation case, Egyptian courts typically require proof that:

• The statement was false.
• The statement was made publicly or shared with a third party.
• The statement damaged the reputation of the victim.
• The defendant acted with malicious intent or reckless disregard for the truth.

2. Criminal Penalties for Defamation:

Under Article 303 of the Penal Code, a person convicted of defamation may face:

• Fines between EGP 5,000 and 30,000 (approx. USD 160 – 960).
• Imprisonment for up to two years.
• Both a fine and imprisonment in aggravated cases.

If the defamatory statement accuses the victim of criminal activity, the punishment increases to three years of imprisonment under Article 308.

3. Defamation Against Public Officials:

Egyptian law provides extra legal protection to public officials, meaning defamation cases involving government ministers, judges, law enforcement officers, and other state authorities carry harsher penalties. This is intended to prevent false accusations that undermine public trust in government institutions.

Civil Liability for Defamation: Compensation for Reputational Harm

Apart from criminal prosecution, defamation victims in Egypt can file civil lawsuits seeking financial compensation for the harm caused to their reputation. The Egyptian Civil Code allows claimants to sue for both economic and moral damages, depending on the circumstances of the case.

1. Legal Grounds for Civil Defamation Claims:

To win a civil defamation case, a plaintiff must prove that:

• The defamatory statement was false.
• The statement harmed their reputation in a way that caused personal, social, or financial damage.
• The defendant acted negligently or with malicious intent.

2. Types of Compensation Available in Civil Defamation Cases:

Egyptian courts may award financial damages in civil defamation cases based on the severity of the defamation and its impact on the victim. Compensation can include moral damages, which account for harm to personal dignity, emotional distress, and damage to social standing. Additionally, plaintiffs can claim economic damages for financial losses suffered due to reputational harm, particularly in business or professional settings where defamation may result in lost opportunities or diminished credibility. Unlike some legal systems that limit compensation to direct financial losses, Egyptian law allows plaintiffs to seek damages for both tangible and intangible harm, ensuring that victims receive full redress for the damage inflicted on their reputation and well-being.

Legal Process for Defamation Cases in Egypt

Defamation cases in Egypt can be pursued through both criminal and civil courts, depending on the nature and severity of the claim. Since defamation is classified as both a criminal offense and a civil wrong, victims have the option to file criminal complaints for prosecution or seek financial compensation through civil litigation. The legal process differs based on which route is chosen, and in many cases, both types of cases run concurrently.

1. Filing a Criminal Defamation Case:

A criminal defamation case in Egypt begins with the victim (plaintiff) filing a complaint with law enforcement authorities or the public prosecution office. The legal steps generally follow this process:

• Complaint Submission: The plaintiff submits an official complaint to the public prosecutor, detailing the false statements made against them, the harm caused, and any available evidence (such as recordings, written statements, or digital communications).
• Prosecutorial Investigation: The public prosecutor reviews the case to determine whether the complaint meets the legal definition of defamation under Articles 302–308 of the Penal Code. If the case is deemed valid, an investigation is opened.
• Summoning the Defendant: If the prosecutor finds sufficient evidence, the accused (defendant) is summoned for questioning and given a chance to provide a defense.
• Criminal Trial Proceedings: If the prosecution moves forward, the case is referred to criminal court, where a judge hears evidence from both parties, testimony from witnesses, and legal arguments.
• Judgment and Sentencing: If found guilty, the defendant may face fines (ranging from EGP 5,000–30,000) or imprisonment for up to three years in aggravated cases.

Criminal defamation cases often proceed relatively quickly. In cases where the court finds insufficient evidence, the complaint may be dismissed without further action.

2. Filing a Civil Defamation Lawsuit:

Unlike criminal defamation cases, civil defamation lawsuits focus on financial compensation for the damage caused to the plaintiff’s reputation, dignity, or business interests. A civil lawsuit follows these steps:

• Filing a Civil Case: The plaintiff submits a statement of claim to a civil court, outlining the nature of the defamation, the harm caused, and the amount of compensation sought.
• Burden of Proof: The plaintiff must demonstrate that:
• The defendant made a false and harmful statement.
• The statement damaged their reputation or caused personal or financial harm.
• The defendant acted negligently or maliciously.
• إجراءات المحكمة: The court evaluates documentary evidence, expert testimony, and witness statements to assess the validity of the claim. The defendant may attempt to argue that their statement was true, an opinion, or justified by public interest.
• Compensation Awarded: If the court rules in favor of the plaintiff, the defendant may be ordered to pay financial damages, covering:
• Moral damages for emotional distress and damage to reputation.
• Economic damages for financial losses suffered due to the defamation.

Defenses Against Defamation Claims in Egypt

Defendants in defamation cases can rely on several legal defenses, but Egyptian law provides fewer protections for freedom of speech compared to jurisdictions like the UK or the United States. The most common defenses include:

• Truth (Limited Defense): Unlike most western countries, where truth is an absolute defense, Egyptian courts may still convict a defendant if the statement, even if true, was made with malicious intent or without a legitimate reason.
• Good Faith and Public Interest: If the defendant can prove that their statement was made in good faith and in the public interest, they may be acquitted. However, Egyptian courts apply this defense very narrowly.
• Opinion vs. Fact: If a statement is a personal opinion rather than a factual claim, it may not be considered defamation. However, insulting or offensive opinions can still be punishable under Egyptian law.
• Consent of the Plaintiff: If the plaintiff previously consented to the publication of the statement, the defendant may argue that no harm was caused.

Egyptian law tends to favor the protection of individual dignity and social order over broad free speech rights, meaning that defendants in defamation cases face significant legal risks.

Appeals and Enforcement of Judgments

Both criminal and civil defamation cases allow for appeals. If a defendant is convicted in a criminal court, they may file an appeal with a higher court, arguing procedural errors, lack of evidence, or an excessive sentence. Similarly, civil judgments awarding compensation can be contested through the appeal process if the defendant believes the damages are excessive or unjustified.

Once a civil defamation judgment is finalized, the plaintiff can enforce the ruling through Egypt’s court enforcement mechanisms, which may include seizing assets or wages if the defendant refuses to pay compensation.

الختام

Defamation law in Egypt is strict and highly punitive, treating false and damaging statements as both a criminal offense and a civil wrong. Unlike many Western jurisdictions where defamation is primarily a civil matter, Egyptian law allows for criminal prosecution, fines, and even imprisonment for those found guilty of making defamatory statements. The legal framework governing defamation is extensive, covering spoken, written, and digital communication, with additional regulations for media and online platforms.

Criminal defamation cases can result in imprisonment for up to three years and significant financial penalties, particularly when the defamatory statement involves public figures or accusations of criminal conduct. Civil defamation lawsuits, on the other hand, enable victims to claim financial compensation for reputational harm, emotional distress, and financial losses. Egyptian courts do not always require proof of economic damage, making it easier for plaintiffs to succeed in defamation claims based on loss of dignity and social standing alone.

As digital communication and social media continue to grow, defamation cases are likely to become more common, particularly in the online sphere. With Egypt’s cybercrime laws expanding liability to online platforms and social media users, individuals and businesses must be cautious when making public statements. The current legal framework provides strong protections for victims of defamation, but also imposes serious consequences on those found guilty, making awareness of defamation laws essential for anyone engaging in public discourse in Egypt.

للمزيد من المعلومات، يرجى ملء النموذج أو إرسال بريد إلكتروني إلى: info@eg.Andersen.com

للتواصل معنا